← All writing

Pound for Pound

AI could let emerging food and beverage brands compete far above their weight, and give them more room for what makes them special.

There’s a definition I come back to often. Adam Morgan, who coined the term challenger brand, describes one as having “business ambitions bigger than its conventional resources.”1

Challenger brands seemed to settle into that description, almost becoming comfortable with doing more with less and leaning on other strengths to succeed: their conviction, their nimbleness, their creativity. Being resource-constrained was just part of the deal. But AI presents a different scenario. With it, smaller brands have access to the equivalent of those conventional resources in a way they never have before.

So, what does it look like when a challenger brand opens up to the idea that its resources can finally match its ambitions?

Being big has its advantages, yet that brings baggage

Large food and beverage companies still take up most of the space. More people, more data, bigger budgets and massive sales organizations. They were built to own distribution.

They were not, however, built for today’s AI opportunity. In BCG’s 2025 survey of 1,250 senior executives, only 5% qualified as “future-built” and were generating substantial value from AI, while 60% reported minimal gains. BCG’s conclusion: companies urgently need to “redesign how work gets done.”2

I’ve lived this. As CMO of Kum & Go, I was the executive sponsor for two major technology initiatives: re-platforming our first-party CRM and implementing an AI-enabled demand planning and forecasting tool. The technology lift was big and hard. It was still small compared with the people and process work of changing how the organization actually ran.

Big companies carry organizational gravity: legacy systems, data silos, agency relationships, approval layers and incentives built around yesterday. For them, AI is a change-management problem as much as a technology one.

The small-brand paradox

A $5 or $50 million company has far less to unwind. It should move faster. Yet it isn’t with respect to using AI as a true force multiplier, at least not yet.

Small brands have always had heart and speed. They spot an opportunity and move. They’re closer to their customers, and they listen better. And increasingly, they’re taking share. Circana found that manufacturers under $1 billion in sales, along with private label, gained share in 2025, while the largest manufacturers continued to lose it.3

But they’re lagging on AI. McKinsey’s 2026 State of AI survey found that 54% of companies with $1 billion or more in revenue are scaling AI across the enterprise, compared with one-third of smaller companies. The gap is also widening in agentic AI: among large companies, the share scaling AI agents jumped from 27% to 40% in a year. Among smaller companies, it stayed flat at 22%.4 For a brand $50 million or less, the gap is likely even wider.

Small brands may have the structural advantage for AI, but not yet the organizational capability to capture it.

The very things that make a small company nimble also make this transition hard. Decisions move fast, but the same lean team can’t realistically redesign the business while running it. There’s no transformation office or strategy team waiting in the wings. So AI gets adopted at the edges, a copywriting tool here, a chatbot there, and the core business keeps running the old way.

Ask a better question

The question most emerging brands ask is, where can we use AI? That’s how you end up with faster emails and cheaper copy. The better question is harder:

If we built this company today, knowing what AI can do, would we organize the work this way at all?

Here’s what that can look like:

  • Insight. Instead of consumer research every few years (or never), an always-on system mines reviews, search, social, customer service and sales data for emerging needs.
  • Sales analytics. Instead of a week wrestling UNFI, KeHE and SPINS reports, AI flags which doors are gaining velocity, which markets are slipping and where distribution has outrun demand.
  • Deductions and trade. Instead of someone chasing retailer and distributor deductions line by line, AI matches them against promo plans and flags what to dispute.
  • Innovation. Instead of weighing a handful of concepts, the team pressure-tests dozens and brings the strongest to people for judgment.
  • Selling. Instead of hours of meeting prep, salespeople start with the account story and a first-draft buyer deck already built.

The point isn’t to eliminate people. It’s to give a 25-person company something closer to the reach of one that once needed 75 people, several agencies and a much bigger budget.

That changes something fundamental about the economics of growing a challenger brand. Historically, revenue scale eventually demanded organizational scale. AI begins to separate the two. A company may be able to build substantially more commercial capability without building proportionately more organizational infrastructure.

AI won’t solve everything. Syndicated data is still expensive, retailer data is still hard to get, and product still has to be made, shipped and sold through. The technology makes it possible to narrow the gap in analytical and creative capacity between a small brand and a big one. Whether emerging brands actually do it is another question. Right now, the adoption data suggests the big companies are moving faster.

Design for pound for pound

In boxing, pound for pound ranks the best fighter regardless of weight class. It asks who is most skilled, not who is biggest. I think that’s the right name for what comes next: the pound-for-pound brand, measured by how much capability it packs into every person and every dollar.

You don’t get there by adding tools. The companies seeing real results changed how the work gets done. In McKinsey’s survey, nearly three-quarters of AI high performers have fundamentally redesigned their workflows, compared with just one-quarter of everyone else.4

For a lean brand, that doesn’t take a transformation office. It does mean getting the basics right. AI can’t make fragmented distributor reports, inconsistent customer definitions or missing door histories magically reliable. The pound-for-pound company doesn’t need a giant data infrastructure, but it does need a trustworthy one. And, then it takes a few deliberate choices:

  • Give the redesign an owner. Someone has to be accountable for how the work changes, not just which software gets bought, even if that’s a part-time role or outside help.
  • Start with a core workflow, not a tool. Pick one that drives growth, like the weekly sales review, promo planning or deductions, and rebuild it end to end.
  • Rethink the roles around it. If AI assembles the analysis, the head of sales spends that time with buyers and brokers. Make that shift part of the job, not a hope.
  • Decide where people make the call. Pricing, brand voice, which ideas move forward. Build human judgment in on purpose.

And keep all of it in service of the growth strategy, not one more pile of software subscriptions.

Special, not small

Here’s the part that excites me most.

The obvious AI story is efficiency: fewer hours spent on spreadsheets, deck-building, data wrangling and repetitive work. But for an emerging brand, the bigger opportunity may be what it chooses to do with the time and capacity it gets back.

Reinvest the AI dividend in differentiation.

More time with customers, building the kind of relationships I wrote about last month. More time on the product. More time in the community. More time sharpening the point of view and telling the story only you can tell.

Those are the things that made challenger brands formidable in the first place. AI doesn’t have to automate them away. It can create more room for them.

For the first time, being small might not mean being under-resourced. It might mean being unusually capable and having more room to be special.

If you lead an emerging food or beverage brand and you’re starting to ask the redesign question, I’d love to hear where you’re beginning.

References

  1. eatbigfish (Adam Morgan), “What Is a Challenger Brand?” — eatbigfish.com
  2. Boston Consulting Group, “AI Leaders Outpace Laggards with Double the Revenue Growth and 40% More Cost Savings” (The Widening AI Value Gap), September 30, 2025. — PR Newswire
  3. Circana, “Circana Announces 2025 U.S. CPG Growth Leaders,” April 9, 2026. — GlobeNewswire
  4. McKinsey & Company, “The State of AI in 2026: On the Road to ROI,” August 25, 2026. — McKinsey.com
Let’s talk

If you are rethinking where your next chapter of growth comes from, let’s talk.

Book a call