← All writing

Where Do You Learn?

Rethinking channel strategy for emerging CPG brands.

I recently spent time with two respected brands whose channel strategies couldn’t be more different.

One turned down a big retail opportunity to go all-in on direct. The math worked on paper — large number of doors and reach — but they concluded the trade-offs weren’t right for where they are: margin pressure, pricing they wouldn’t fully control, and energy pulled away from the direct customer relationships that built the brand in the first place.

The other sees DTC from the opposite direction: as the last stage of the customer journey, not the first. Customers discover the brand out in the world — through wholesale accounts, at retail, on Amazon — and only later, once they’re loyal, come direct for the products they can’t get anywhere else. DTC isn’t a focal point there; it’s an outcome.

I don’t see either as right or wrong. They’re both responding to channel dynamics, and together they point to the power a channel has over a business. Brands always face the choice: chase every channel and burn out, or narrow focus and hope enough customers find you anyway. I don’t know which came first — whether channel power forced channel thinking, or whether businesses have always thought in channel-first terms.

What I do know, after years inside brands navigating these exact decisions, is that shoppers don’t think in channels at all.

Shoppers don’t think in channels

They’re omni-channel by nature, and even more so today. According to a 2025 report from FMI and NielsenIQ, more than 90% of grocery shoppers now buy both in-store and online — through retailer apps, websites, marketplaces, and social platforms, where over half of consumers have purchased directly. The younger the shopper, the more fluid the behavior: a majority of Gen Z and millennials prefer a blend of online and in-store shopping, and roughly 80% of 18–24-year-olds check a retailer’s website before, during, or after shopping in a physical store.

Gen Z bounces between Amazon, Thrive, TikTok Shop, and the aisles of Whole Foods without ever thinking about the channel dynamics a brand has to — and without ever knowing what trade spend really costs an emerging brand. And the fluidity is compounding: agentic shoppers are already shaping choices, and AI is quickly becoming a distribution layer for the very content brands rely on to entice discovery.

The way shoppers discover, learn, engage, and attach to brands is ever more fluid, which makes channel decisions ever more difficult. And it points to the real trap:

Most brands optimize a channel before they’ve learned enough about their customers.

Every channel teaches you something different

We tend to talk about channels as places to sell. I think it’s more useful to talk about them as places to learn — because they’re not interchangeable, and each one creates a fundamentally different relationship with the customer.

Retail teaches velocity, pricing, and merchandising — and whether you move. It tells you if your product sells when nobody’s there to explain it.

DTC teaches motivations, objections, language, and identity — why people buy, in their own words.

Subscriptions teach habit. Communities teach advocacy.

You can hit every velocity target and still not know why anyone buys you.

Neither of the two brands I described is confused about this. The one that turned down big retail is protecting its ability to learn directly. The one treating DTC as an outcome has hundreds of wholesale doors doing its discovery work, human to human, every day. Each knows where its learning comes from. That’s rarer than it should be.

Here’s the simple framework I keep coming back to:

Channel What it primarily gives you
RetailReach
DTCRelationship
SubscriptionHabit
CommunityAdvocacy & learning
SocialDiscovery
WholesaleAvailability

None of these is “best.” Retail creates scale. DTC creates learning. Subscriptions create habit. Communities create advocacy. The mistake isn’t picking one — it’s picking one without knowing what you’re giving up, or what you still need to learn.

The real asset isn’t shelf space

Channels don’t just move products; they create different relationships with customers. And a brand’s greatest asset is its relationship with its customers. That relationship is easy to lose, and it tends to slip away quietly — at exactly the moment your energy shifts from connecting with people to “managing the channel.”

So before your next channel decision, ask two questions:

  • What will this channel teach us about our customers?
  • What will we stop learning while our energy is there?
Not just where to sell. Where to learn.

Why this matters more right now

Here’s what’s changed: staying close to customers used to require being small. Now it mostly requires deciding to.

With AI, there has never been a better time to stay close. The signal was always out there — in reviews, Reddit threads, search queries, support tickets, subscription cancel reasons, recipe comments, creator content, retailer reviews, email replies, purchase histories. What’s new is that a small team can actually synthesize it, at any scale, in any channel mix.

And yet many brands still behave as if the retailer owns the relationship — as if customer understanding is something you trade away for distribution.

Companies spend enormous energy following channel dynamics. They should spend more of it following customers.

This is the work I’m focusing on. After years inside brands, I now advise emerging CPG companies on exactly this — and it’s what I’ll be writing about here: how every channel can make you smarter, not just bigger, because I believe that’s what this moment requires. If you’re wrestling with a channel decision right now, I’d love to compare notes.

Sources

  • FMI / NielsenIQ 2025 omnichannel grocery report, via Grocery Dive and FMI
  • Generational omnichannel behavior: Capital One Shopping research compilation (drawing on NRF, Statista, McKinsey, eMarketer)
Let’s talk

If you are rethinking where your next chapter of growth comes from, let’s talk.

Book a call